Lady Luck's influence on Knockout leagues is growing ever greater.
Bad fortune in the injury department spawned the largest knockout rate by any individual player all season in Week 10. Drake Maye's likely season-ending fractured ankle not only set back his New England Patriots' playoff chances, but also eliminated his Knockout teams in 21.7% of leagues.
Brock Bowers' own ankle injury landed him high on the list, as he played only 19% of the Las Vegas Raiders' snaps, scored a season-low 3.8 fantasy points and was on knocked-out teams in 13.1% of leagues. Fellow tight end Travis Kelce, who battled ankle and calf issues in what was a 5.0-fantasy-point Week 10, was on knocked-out teams in 12.0% of leagues. Meanwhile, Kenneth Walker III and Puka Nacua, both ruled out in advance of their games, had 16.3% and 12.8% knockout rates.
But it's not only injuries that prove problematic at this midseason stage of Knockout leagues. Unfortunate outcomes, especially those in what were favorable matchups on paper, prove comparably devastating. Chris Olave scored 6.0 fantasy points and had a 13.1% knockout rate, while his WR1 counterpart from that same game, Tetairoa McMillan, scored 6.5 points and was knocked out in 12.2% of leagues. Jonathan Taylor scored 12.3 points and had a 12.2% knockout rate.
It's fantasy football, and anything can happen. But that doesn't mean we should adopt a throw-up-our-hands, aw-shucks type of approach. Rather, the increasingly devastating effects of such unexpected bad outcomes reminds us of two critical Knockout strategies as we progress through the season's second half:
Upside becomes increasingly important each successive week, in order to give us the high-level scores to neutralize these untimely stinkers, and
Bad matchups are a no today, and they're a no tomorrow, a NO the next week, and so on.
As Week 11 dawns, it's that latter point that rings loudest.
We saw the impact of that must-avoid Minnesota Vikings matchup in Week 10, as once-red-hot Green Bay Packers players Jordan Love, Christian Watson and Matthew Golden all finished with 12 or fewer fantasy points, and each of them resided on knocked-out teams in at least 11% of leagues. That comes on the heels of Josh Allen scoring a season-low 12.86 fantasy points against those same Vikings in Week 9, leading to his teams' elimination in 13.1% of leagues.
This week, we've got several significant fantasy football superstars facing the two all-around toughest matchups: The Detroit Lions and San Francisco 49ers, both of whom rank among the top five offenses in terms of points and yards per game, draw the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Vikings.
This isn't to say that Jahmyr Gibbs, Christian McCaffrey and Amon-Ra St. Brown are all instant sits due to the relative downside of their matchups. None of the three has had a single-week knockout rate greater than 13% all season, and they've had sub-5% rates in 53% of their weeks as a group so far. What it does remind, however, is that any lineup reliant upon the three to survive should consider surrounding them with an additional high-ceiling matchup (or 2-3) as a neutralization attempt.
That means perhaps a Dak Prescott (TEN), Jonah Coleman (LV), Luther Burden III (NO) or Carnell Tate (@DAL) would prove especially advantageous to those managers.
Highest knockout rates from Week 10
FAB recommendations in the chart below follow these guidelines: "% OF FAB TO BID (ENFORCE)" represents the low end, if the player isn't a must, but you don't want him gifted to the competition. "% OF FAB TO BID (MEDIAN)" is the median bid for a team with average needs at the position. "% OF FAB TO BID (AGGRESSIVE)" suggests a go-get-him bid for teams in need at that position.
My favorite pickup of the week
Brock Bowers, TE, Raiders (13.1% knocked out, fourth overall, TE1): That my favorite FAB target is a player who will likely enter Week 11 questionable at best due to an ankle injury, not to mention has his bye week ahead of him (Week 13), tells you all you need to know about "automatics" on the free-agency front. Most every widely available player this week faces some significant question, from injury (Nacua) to schedule (Watson) to role (Kyren Williams) to his quarterback (Trey McBride). Assuming Bowers' ankle injury isn't as serious as initially feared, he brings advantages in terms of his schedule, as three of his next six games come against top-eight schedule adjusted tight end matchups and another two come against seasonal upper-half or top-eight past five week positional matchups. The Raiders also seem likely to have generally pass-friendly game script with rookie Fernando Mendoza under center moving forward, with Bowers serving as Mendoza's clear WR1. Recommended FAB bid: 14-31% of your full-season FAB budget.
But there's a lesson here: This -- and perhaps no upcoming week -- isn't an all-in kind of week on free agency, unless you're one of the lucky ones to reside in one of the 1.8%, 5.4%, 3.8% or 1.6% of Knockout leagues in which Gibbs, Jaxon Smith-Njigba, Ja'Marr Chase or McCaffrey are available.
Go get 'em
Bucky Irving, RB, Buccaneers (12.8% knocked out, seventh overall, RB1): He's having a remarkably productive season, and having a healthy Baker Mayfield back under center has fueled massive touch and fantasy point totals for Irving of late. In Mayfield's five fully healthy games, Irving has averaged 21.4 fantasy points and 22.4 touches; Irving's averages are 13.1 and 19.3 in his other four contests. Being fresh off the bye week is a plus, and Irving has three top-tier matchups remaining (CAR, Week 12; NO, Week 15, @ATL, Week 16), which is especially appealing for late-season Knockout play. Better yet, he's probably not going to cost as much in FAB as your brand-name, elite running backs. Recommended FAB bid: 17-41%.
Chris Olave, WR, New Orleans Saints (13.1% knocked out, third overall, WR2): He -- and the Saints' offense as a whole -- has been one of the more statistically volatile players over the past six weeks, but his status as the team's alpha receiver keeps him in the upper tiers of the wide receiver rankings. Olave's 27% target share is more than 10% greater than the next-closest Saint, making him one of seven WR1s across the league who can claim that, and he has a quartet of above-average remaining matchups: @CIN in Week 12, GB in Week 13, @CAR in Week 14 and @ATL in Week 17. At this Knockout stage, upside and elite matchups are what you want, particularly at the wide receiver position. Recommended FAB bid: 12-28%.
Kenneth Walker III, RB, Kansas City Chiefs (12.8% knocked out, eighth overall, RB2): He's expected to return from a groin injury for Week 11, and perhaps the week's rest will do him some good down the stretch. Walker's 24.6 fantasy points per game average is sixth-best among all players, not just running backs, and he's averaging 23.1 touches as the centerpiece of the league's No. 2 offense in yardage and No. 7 in scoring. Recommended FAB bid: 25-49%.
Worthy, with worries
Trey McBride, TE, Arizona Cardinals (12.3% knocked out, 10th overall, TE2): I waffle between him and Bowers, ultimately highlighting the latter while slotting the former in the "worries" section, despite the fact that McBride is the healthier of the two. McBride's rookie quarterback, Carson Beck, seemed at an early point on his NFL learning curve in his first career start, and the Cardinals, like the Raiders, have their bye week upcoming (Week 14). I still regard McBride an appealing, high-volume type, and still consider Bowers and him TE1 and TE1A, but my mental coin flip goes in Bowers' direction. But the gap between them and the next-closest tight end has narrowed. Recommended FAB bid: 13-33%.
Jordan Love, QB, Packers (13.0% knocked out, sixth overall, QB2): He's one of the most prominent players who will spend "bye-mageddon" Week 11 on the sidelines, meaning he's plenty likely to find himself high on next week's list, too. Love has been excellent this season, but he's still playing very much to his matchups, with his two worst single-game scores coming against defenses that rank among the three toughest for quarterbacks. He's a worthy pickup, but from a strategic standpoint, the increasing level of ease mixing and matching your quarterbacks makes him only a modest target. Recommended FAB bid: 10-18%.
Christian Watson and Matthew Golden, WRs, Packers (12.0% and 11.4% knocked out, 14th and 22nd overall, WR6 and WR9): Love's receivers, meanwhile, are more worthy pickups due to their elevated statistical ceilings in plus matchups. That said, their Week 11 bye makes them challenging additions today, and it's important to note that the Packers have one of the toughest remaining schedules for wide receivers. Recommended FAB bid: 11-25% for each; I personally prefer Golden.
No thanks
Puka Nacua, WR, Los Angeles Rams (16.3% knocked out, 2nd overall, WR1): I want to make the case that he's a worthwhile IR-spot stash, assuming you have yours open, but it's a difficult sell. Nacua is sidelined until at least Week 15, the rust factor casts some doubt upon what would've been an otherwise appealing Dallas Cowboys matchup in that week, and he'd have two of the toughest matchups for a wide receiver thereafter (@SEA, @TB). He's more of a wait-and-see player than one to stash for a low-level bid. Recommended FAB bid: 0-5%.
